⚠️ Mature Audience Only
This story contains themes suitable for adults. Please proceed only if you are 18+.
J.E. Nickerson
The knock was soft enough that Samantha almost dismissed it as part of a dream. A faint brush of sound against her front door — too gentle to be a threat, too deliberate to ignore.
She opened her eyes.
Dark room.
The faint rise and fall of Steven sleeping beside her, his arm draped loosely over her waist. She could feel his steady warmth, the quiet trust in the way he slept around her. It grounded her — but only for a moment.
Her eyes went to the clock beside her
4:13 a.m.
The kind of hour when only trouble knows your name.
The knock came again.
A patient one.
Measured.
Like someone testing the edge of a truth they weren’t sure they wanted to tell.
Samantha carefully slid out from under Steven’s arm, letting the mattress rise slowly so he wouldn’t wake. The warmth of his body was replaced with the chill of the night. A reminder that the job always pulled her away—even now.
Barefoot, she moved through the apartment, keeping the lights off. Darkness made people honest. It stripped away performance, left only the raw outline of intent.
The thin line of streetlamp glow cut across the front window. In that muted amber, she saw the shape of a man standing on her porch — broad shouldered, motionless, as if carved from something heavier than stone.
Her pulse tightened, but not with fear. With recognition.
This was the kind of knock people saved for her.
Not police.
Not detectives.
Her.
Because some stories were too dangerous for anyone else.
And some people trusted crime reporters more than police.
“Ms. Leary?” The man’s voice was low, controlled. The kind of control built over years of swallowing things too hard to say.
She didn’t answer.
He shifted slightly, just enough to suggest he knew she was there. “Please… I need help.”
Samantha unlocked the deadbolt but didn’t open the door. “Say your name.”
A beat.
Two.
Three.
“I can’t,” he murmured. “If I tell you, you won’t open the door.”
“I’m not opening it either way.”
A soft exhale — not quite a laugh, not quite defeat. “Fair.”
He adjusted his stance. Not leaving. Just rearranging himself in the dark like a man preparing to confess to the wrong person.
“My daughter,” he said quietly. “She’s missing.”
Samantha’s breath stilled.
Missing children had a way of cutting through all the protective layers she’d built as a reporter. They were the stories she never wanted but always answered.
“How long?” she asked.
“Eight hours.”
“And you didn’t call the police.”
Silence.
thick, heavy.
“You came here instead,” she said.
He nodded. She only saw the outline of it, but the weight of the gesture carried through the wood.
“How did you find me?”
He hesitated, gaze dropping. “I’ve been watching you for a few days. I needed to know you weren’t like the others.”
“What aren’t you telling me?”
His breathing hitched. Barely noticeable — but Samantha noticed.
“It’s my brother,” he finally said. “I think he took her.”
The temperature in the room seemed to shift. Familial violence had its own gravity — a quiet, poisonous one.
“Why would he take her?” Samantha asked.
The man swallowed hard. “I don’t know. But I trusted him. And I… I ignored things I shouldn’t have.”
He dragged a hand over his mouth, eyes unfocused. “He always said she was hiding things. That she had this secret life I didn’t know about. A few weeks ago he said he’d make her tell. Make her confess. And I—” his voice cracked. “I shouldn’t have pushed it aside. Should’ve… taken it more seriously.”
Samantha unlocked the second latch but still didn’t open the door. Her voice softened, but only by degrees. “Step back. Let me see your hands.”
He stepped into the glow of the streetlamp. Hands visible, open, shaking only a little.
But Samantha saw it:
fear wasn’t the only thing living in his posture.
There was something else.
Something he was holding back.
Something he hoped she wouldn’t see until she’d invited him closer.
Samantha could hear Steven in the bedroom—soft movement, the brief rush of water from the bathroom. The sound grounded her. At least he was awake. At least she wasn’t alone if the man on her doorstep turned volatile.
She kept her eyes on him, steady, giving nothing away.
“Good,” she murmured. “Stay right there.”
She closed the door and took a deep breath.
Whatever story he brought to her doorstep, she knew one thing with absolute clarity:
People rarely came to a reporter at 4 a.m. unless they were hiding the most dangerous part of the truth.
Samantha Leary Psychological Thrillers
Step into Samantha Leary’s world—where hidden secrets, control, and obsession dominate the lives of victims. Can she uncover the truth before it’s too late? Explore the series and experience the suspense for yourself.
Enter her world here
Step into the series on Amazon
For Mature Audiences Only
Discover more from We Are Wise Thinkers
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
We Are Wise Thinkers 